If the insurance company is lowballing your injury claim in Missouri, do not accept it, do not sign anything, and do not give a recorded statement. A low first offer is standard practice, not a final valuation — it is made early, before your treatment is complete, precisely because the insurer knows your claim is worth more later. In Missouri you have five years to file most injury lawsuits, so there is almost never a reason to accept a fast offer. Missouri also gives injured people specific statutory leverage most states do not, including the vexatious refusal statute (RSMo § 375.420) and the time-limited demand procedure (RSMo § 537.058). Before you respond to any offer, call Sansone & Lauber at 314-863-0500. Free consultation.
Why Is the Insurance Company Offering So Little?
Because it usually works. Adjusters are evaluated on claim severity — how little they pay per file. An early offer is made when your leverage is at its lowest: bills are arriving, you may be out of work, and the full extent of your injury is not yet documented.
Common tactics behind a low number:
- Offering before you reach maximum medical improvement, so future treatment and permanent impairment are excluded from the math
- Valuing only your emergency room bill and ignoring ongoing care, therapy, or surgery you have not had yet
- Using a claims software estimate rather than an individual evaluation of your injury
- Blaming a “gap in treatment” when you could not afford to keep going to the doctor
- Attributing your injury to a pre-existing condition disclosed in records they obtained from an overly broad authorization
- Assigning you a share of fault to reduce the offer under Missouri’s comparative fault rules
- Using your recorded statement against you — casual remarks like “I’m doing okay” become evidence
- Delaying until financial pressure makes any number look acceptable
- Ignoring lost wages and future earning capacity entirely unless you document and demand them
What Should I Do Right Now?
- Do not accept, and do not sign a release. A signed release permanently ends the claim, even if you need surgery next month.
- Get the offer in writing, along with the adjuster’s stated basis for it.
- Decline the recorded statement. You are not required to give one to the other driver’s insurer.
- Do not sign a blanket medical authorization. Broad authorizations let the insurer mine your entire medical history for a pre-existing condition defense.
- Keep treating. Gaps in care are the single most-used argument against injury claims.
- Document everything — bills, mileage, missed work, out-of-pocket costs, and how the injury affects daily life.
- Find every applicable policy. Your own underinsured motorist coverage often matters more than the at-fault driver’s limits.
- Do not post about the accident or your activities on social media. Adjusters look.
- Watch the deadline — generally five years, but as short as 90 days if a government entity is involved.
- Talk to a Missouri injury attorney before responding. The consultation is free and what you say next affects the value of the claim.
What Legal Leverage Do I Have Under Missouri Law?
This is where Missouri differs meaningfully from other states.
Vexatious refusal to pay — RSMo § 375.420
If an insurer refuses to pay a covered loss without reasonable cause or excuse, Missouri law allows recovery of the amount owed plus a penalty of up to 20% of the first $1,500 of the loss and 10% of the amount above that, plus reasonable attorney’s fees. Under RSMo § 375.296, the insurer must have failed to pay for 30 days after demand before suit is filed.
The critical limitation: § 375.420 expressly excludes automobile liability insurance. It is a first-party remedy — it applies to your own insurer on your uninsured motorist, underinsured motorist, MedPay, health, or property coverage. You generally cannot bring a vexatious refusal claim directly against the at-fault driver’s liability carrier. Many websites get this wrong. If your own insurer is stonewalling your UM or UIM claim, this statute is a serious tool.
Time-limited settlement demands — RSMo § 537.058
When your damages clearly exceed the at-fault driver’s policy limits, a properly constructed policy-limits demand creates real exposure for the insurer. If the carrier unreasonably rejects it and a jury later returns a verdict above the limits, the insurer may be responsible for the excess.
Missouri regulates these demands closely. To count as a reasonable opportunity to settle, the demand must:
- Be sent to the at-fault driver’s liability insurer by certified mail, return receipt requested
- Reference the statute expressly
- Remain open at least 90 days from the insurer’s receipt
- State a specific dollar amount or demand the applicable policy limits
- Identify who is released and what claims are released
- Provide an unconditional release of the insured
- Include the claim number, date and location of the loss, and a description of injuries
- Be accompanied by a list of treating providers and HIPAA-compliant authorizations, plus employer information and authorizations if wage loss is claimed
A demand that does not comply is inadmissible in later bad faith litigation. This is precisely the kind of procedural detail where doing it yourself forfeits the leverage the statute was designed to give you.
Filing a complaint with the state
Missouri’s Department of Commerce and Insurance accepts consumer complaints against licensed insurers. A complaint does not resolve your claim, but it creates a regulatory record and sometimes prompts movement on a file that has stalled.
How Does Missouri’s Comparative Fault Rule Affect a Lowball Offer?
Adjusters frequently assign injured people a share of fault to justify a lower number. Missouri follows pure comparative fault: your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault, but you are never barred from recovering. Even a person found 80% at fault can recover 20% of their damages.
An adjuster telling you that partial fault means no claim is either mistaken or hoping you are.
When Should You Say Yes?
Not every offer is a lowball. An offer is worth serious consideration when your treatment is genuinely complete, the offer accounts for future care and lost earning capacity, liability is disputed on real evidence, and the offer approaches the available policy limits.
The honest test is not whether the number feels low. It is whether the number reflects your full documented damages against the coverage that actually exists.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I accept the insurance company’s first offer in Missouri?
Rarely. First offers are typically made before treatment is complete and before future medical costs and lost earning capacity are documented. Accepting requires signing a release that permanently closes the claim.
Can I sue an insurance company for bad faith in Missouri?
Missouri’s primary remedy is the vexatious refusal statute, RSMo § 375.420, which applies to first-party claims against your own insurer and expressly excludes automobile liability insurance. It allows recovery of a statutory penalty plus reasonable attorney’s fees when an insurer refuses payment without reasonable cause.
What is vexatious refusal to pay in Missouri?
An insurer’s refusal to pay a covered loss without reasonable cause or excuse. Under RSMo § 375.420 the policyholder may recover up to 20% of the first $1,500 of the loss, 10% of the amount above $1,500, and reasonable attorney’s fees, in addition to the amount owed.
How long do I have to settle or sue in Missouri?
Generally five years for personal injury and three years for wrongful death. Claims against a city, county, or state entity may require written notice within 90 days.
Do I have to give the insurance company a recorded statement?
You are not required to give one to the at-fault driver’s insurer. Your own policy may require cooperation, but you should speak with an attorney before giving any statement.
What if the at-fault driver’s insurance isn’t enough?
Your own underinsured motorist coverage may pay the difference up to your limit. Missouri requires uninsured motorist coverage on every auto policy, and reviewing every policy in your household is often the highest-value step in a serious claim.
Can the insurance company use my social media against me?
Yes. Photos, check-ins, and comments are routinely used to argue an injury is less severe than claimed.
Will hiring a lawyer make the insurance company offer more?
Insurers evaluate whether a claimant’s attorney actually files suit and tries cases. That assessment affects every offer. Industry research also shows litigation and attorney involvement in auto injury claims have risen substantially in recent years.
What does it cost to have a lawyer review my offer?
Nothing. Sansone & Lauber offers free consultations and works on contingency — no fee unless we win.
What if the insurance company just stops responding?
Delay is a tactic. If your own insurer is involved, a formal written demand starts the 30-day clock under RSMo § 375.296 that precedes a vexatious refusal claim. Document every attempted contact.
Serving Injured People Across Missouri
Sansone & Lauber represents clients throughout the state, including St. Louis, St. Louis County, Clayton, Chesterfield, St. Charles, O’Fallon, Kansas City, Independence, Lee’s Summit, Springfield, Columbia, Jefferson City, Joplin, St. Joseph, Cape Girardeau, and Branson — as well as in Illinois.
Do Not Answer a Lowball Offer Alone
The adjuster handling your file does this every day. The offer on the table was calculated with the expectation that you would take it.
Sansone & Lauber has handled personal injury and wrongful death cases exclusively since 2003. We have taken cases to verdict when insurers refused to pay fairly — including a $14.2 million jury verdict in a motorcycle brain injury case where the pre-trial offer was $200,000.
Call Sansone & Lauber at 314-863-0500 before you accept anything.
Free consultation. Available 24/7. No fee unless we win.
Sansone & Lauber
7777 Bonhomme Ave, Suite 2100
St. Louis, MO 63105
314-863-0500
Site by Consultwebs.com: Law Firm Website Designers/Personal Injury Lawyer Marketing.